Why this verdict
- suspicious: finding skill:skills/triaging-security-incident-with-ir-playbook:skills/triaging-security-incident-with-ir-playbook/SKILL.md:133:EXEC
Security findings 1
Code execution
highContextual riskmedium confidenceSKILL.md Steps 3 and 5 instruct the agent to read and follow IR playbook content (cat/grep) from /opt/ir/playbooks/, files the artifact does not ship, so triage behavior applies whatever occupies that runtime path.
cat /opt/ir/playbooks/ransomware_playbook.yaml
vector:instruction
Counter-argument considered
Strongest refutation case is the declared description's 'using structured IR playbooks' plus the read-only nature of cat/grep, but no declaration covers loading and applying unvalidated content from the host path /opt/ir/playbooks/ at runtime (declared claims are empty), and the concrete instruction to ingest whatever occupies those unshipped paths into triage behavior and downstream response actions is a live source→sink chain that absence of the files never neutralizes.
Open questions 8
What the analysis could not settle from the code alone.
Do the /opt/ir/playbooks/ files referenced by SKILL.md (trigger_conditions.yaml and the *_playbook.yaml files) exist on target hosts, and what instructions do they contain? The artifact does not ship them, so what the agent would load and apply at runtime is unknowable from the evidence shown.
Code execution
[file request opt/ir/playbooks/phishing_playbook.yaml] SKILL.md Step 5 also instructs the agent to cat this playbook file; is it shipped in the repository and if so what instructions does it contain?
Code execution
[file request opt/ir/playbooks/unauthorized_access_playbook.yaml] SKILL.md Step 5 also instructs the agent to cat this playbook file; is it shipped in the repository and if so what instructions does it contain?
Code execution
[file request opt/ir/playbooks/trigger_conditions.yaml] SKILL.md Step 3 greps this trigger-conditions file; is it shipped in the repository and if so what instructions does it contain?
Code execution
[file request opt/ir/playbooks/ransomware_playbook.yaml] SKILL.md Step 5 instructs the agent to cat this playbook file; is it shipped in the repository and if so what instructions does it contain?
Code execution
[file request /opt/ir/playbooks/ransomware_playbook.yaml] SKILL.md Step 5 instructs the agent to read this playbook file; does the repository ship it, and if so what instructions does it contain?
Code execution
[file request /opt/ir/playbooks/trigger_conditions.yaml] SKILL.md Step 3 greps this file for playbook trigger conditions; does the repository ship it, and if so what does it contain?
Code execution
[file request /opt/ir/playbooks/trigger_conditions.yaml] Is the playbook trigger-conditions file referenced by SKILL.md Step 3 shipped anywhere in the repository, or is it NOT IN REPOSITORY (host-only content the agent would read at runtime)?
Code execution